Goody-Pie

 Goody-Pie

    This recipe is the last of the choices I gave when I had a poll to see what I should make.  The winner was Vegetable Dish, so I made the Spanish Lima casserole, then it was the Meat Dish (Donna James' Salisbury Steak) and now this, Dessert.  Reading the recipe, it is clear it is not a pie, but more of a "crisp".  It's a pretty easy recipe and I enjoyed making it. However, although it tasted good, I wished I had not chopped the apples so small and it was way too much sugar. And, I was on FaceTime with a friend and accidentally put 1 teaspoon each of baking powder and baking soda instead of 1/4 teaspoon of each.  I figured at least they were equal amounts; at least I was consistent with that. *It didn't really affect the taste* I plan to try this recipe again, only I will double the amount of apple, and will use less sugar.  I'll take out the single cup of white sugar mixed with the apples before the topping with has more sugar in it. Because I'll be doubling the amount of apple, I'll also use a bigger baking dish.  

    I started by melting the 1/3 cup butter, so it could cool while I was fixing the apples (cutting, peeling and chopping) and mixing the dry ingredients for the topping.   The recipe says you can also sprinkle lemon juice over the apples, which I didn't do, to help prevent the fruit from turning brown.  I used two decent, good sized honey-crisp apples, which were just a tad over 3 cups. You can sprinkle cinnamon over the apples in the dish, if desired.  I chose to mix 1 teaspoon cinnamon in with the white sugar and then poured that over the apples, which I had spread in my round baking dish.  I combined the dry ingredients for the topping together in the order listed and stirred in the cooled butter with a fork at first and then used my clean hands to make sure it was completely mixed.  Next I spread the topping mixture over the apples and put it in my oven for 45, which I had pre-heated to 350 degrees.  The recipe says "a moderate oven" and I figure 350 degrees is pretty standard. My kitchen started smelling really good pretty quickly. It was awesome!!

    When my baking time was up, some of the topping still looked "dry", but I think that happens with a lot of crumbles/crisps. It was a nice, dark brown bubbly color around the outside though.  I served myself a small dish with some whipped topping and then remembered I had maple flavored whipped topping in a can, so I tried some of that also and it was awesome!!!! I will say though that I did not eat all of the gooey goodness on the bottom of my bowl, but that wasn't because of the taste, it was because it was just so sweet.  I hate to say it, but I didn't save what was left, because of the overpowering sweetness.  After I did that though someone I talked to about it suggested using bits of it on top of oatmeal and then I was kicking myself, because I thought that would have been a great idea to be able to at least use some of it. 

    Anyhow, like I said up top, I liked this dessert and will make it again, but with less sugar and more apples.  If you try it, let me know if you like it.  You may be okay with the full amount of sugar, so it's up to you if you want to try it. Using more apple and a bigger pan might help.  

    This recipe was submitted to the cookbook which started this all by a Mrs. W. O. Abram.